Thursday, December 13, 2012
for the record
my own personal spouse thinks the below is greatly exaggerated, if not downright misrepresentative. the class rubbed someone the wrong way, which led to a fairly dramatic episode, but it must be said that a lot of students seem to be doing just fine, thank you very much, and also seem to be evincing actual learning and also good will. still though, i wouldn't have all four of you reading the blog if i told less dramatic stories, now would i?
no one ever learns anything at all, to exaggerate only slightly
this semester i taught a graduate seminar-- Intro to Theory, a required class for MA students here at my large southern public technology-oriented research university. apparently it did not go well, and i think that while i am not a perfect teacher, many of the most relevant reasons it did not go well are, i believe, unrelated to me.
first of all, in my academic career i have noticed that more people than not have weirdly personal responses to the body of work called Theory. they treat it like a religion-- either wholeheartedly embracing it and acting like dogmatic true believers, or suspiciously resisting it, as if Theory is trying to change their lives or make them do something they don't want to. almost no one treats it like something to read and understand and engage with professionally and intellectually. what's up with that? it's a significant part of the intellectual history of their chosen discipline, like shakespeare or the harlem renaissance, and yet it is treated as if it is something you have to "accept" or "reject."*
also. and this is delicate. people entering master's programs in english were usually really good, conscientious and engaged undergraduates. they were often big fish in small ponds. in graduate school, the pond turns into more of a lake, or maybe even they catch a glimpse of the ocean. some respond to this disturbing view by digging into their pond and insisting they still are very big. as really good and conscientious undergraduates they may or may not have developed some habits that are unsuited to the new environment. habits like saving work for the last minute, or feeling satisfied with righteous political pronouncements or extremely personal revelatory stories, or skimming assigned reading. having experienced a range of perspectives in these situations, i happen to know that this behavior is often very highly rewarded in many contexts. it is unsuited to a theory class, and many graduate contexts.
so a lot of people who were great undergrads show up to grad school expecting the system of rewards for self-satisfaction and cursory work to continue. and the text of theory really puts the brakes on that. it is not amenable to reading habits that have always worked for them. it also implicitly delivers the news that the reader is not hot shit. again, though: if you don't take it personally (as you wouldn't take mary shelley or t.s. eliot personally), but only take it as something to read and understand, it wouldn't matter. this question remains!
also though, at the end of every semester you, the professor, find out that you have not been having the transparent exchanges of information and ideas you thought you had been having all semester. you find out that you exist as students' fantasies about what school and professors and authority and education and learning are supposed to be. you also find out that your subject position--your age and gender and reproductive status and educational background, etc.--plays a significant part in those fantasies.**
so if you have a situation in which a student resists the idea that they are not hot shit (because no one is, but that's not the point), and you, the professor, are the one who seems to be the person who invented and then delivered that information, and you, the professor seem to not be validating entrenched habits, and if you, the professor, are not the kind of woman, mother, authority figure, intellectual, teacher, therapist, or priestess that the student has in mind to validate their identity, then you, the professor, are well and truly an object of contempt, for reasons totally unrelated to your faulty teaching. and then it's clinched that nobody, including you, has learned or will learn anything. and there you have it!
*you know what else is like that? evolution. people think evolution is something you choose to believe or not believe, unlike gravity or the roundness of the earth. SO WEIRD!
**i happen to think that this phenomenon is spread far wider than just the teaching situation-- i am aware of how lots of people project onto you the kind of person they believe you are supposed to be based on their own investments, and i think that the best and closest and most trustworthy companions are the ones whose fantasies match up with your own, i.e. listen to and understand you. but i digress.
first of all, in my academic career i have noticed that more people than not have weirdly personal responses to the body of work called Theory. they treat it like a religion-- either wholeheartedly embracing it and acting like dogmatic true believers, or suspiciously resisting it, as if Theory is trying to change their lives or make them do something they don't want to. almost no one treats it like something to read and understand and engage with professionally and intellectually. what's up with that? it's a significant part of the intellectual history of their chosen discipline, like shakespeare or the harlem renaissance, and yet it is treated as if it is something you have to "accept" or "reject."*
also. and this is delicate. people entering master's programs in english were usually really good, conscientious and engaged undergraduates. they were often big fish in small ponds. in graduate school, the pond turns into more of a lake, or maybe even they catch a glimpse of the ocean. some respond to this disturbing view by digging into their pond and insisting they still are very big. as really good and conscientious undergraduates they may or may not have developed some habits that are unsuited to the new environment. habits like saving work for the last minute, or feeling satisfied with righteous political pronouncements or extremely personal revelatory stories, or skimming assigned reading. having experienced a range of perspectives in these situations, i happen to know that this behavior is often very highly rewarded in many contexts. it is unsuited to a theory class, and many graduate contexts.
so a lot of people who were great undergrads show up to grad school expecting the system of rewards for self-satisfaction and cursory work to continue. and the text of theory really puts the brakes on that. it is not amenable to reading habits that have always worked for them. it also implicitly delivers the news that the reader is not hot shit. again, though: if you don't take it personally (as you wouldn't take mary shelley or t.s. eliot personally), but only take it as something to read and understand, it wouldn't matter. this question remains!
also though, at the end of every semester you, the professor, find out that you have not been having the transparent exchanges of information and ideas you thought you had been having all semester. you find out that you exist as students' fantasies about what school and professors and authority and education and learning are supposed to be. you also find out that your subject position--your age and gender and reproductive status and educational background, etc.--plays a significant part in those fantasies.**
so if you have a situation in which a student resists the idea that they are not hot shit (because no one is, but that's not the point), and you, the professor, are the one who seems to be the person who invented and then delivered that information, and you, the professor seem to not be validating entrenched habits, and if you, the professor, are not the kind of woman, mother, authority figure, intellectual, teacher, therapist, or priestess that the student has in mind to validate their identity, then you, the professor, are well and truly an object of contempt, for reasons totally unrelated to your faulty teaching. and then it's clinched that nobody, including you, has learned or will learn anything. and there you have it!
*you know what else is like that? evolution. people think evolution is something you choose to believe or not believe, unlike gravity or the roundness of the earth. SO WEIRD!
**i happen to think that this phenomenon is spread far wider than just the teaching situation-- i am aware of how lots of people project onto you the kind of person they believe you are supposed to be based on their own investments, and i think that the best and closest and most trustworthy companions are the ones whose fantasies match up with your own, i.e. listen to and understand you. but i digress.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
