Wednesday, August 31, 2011

natural childbirth

recently i produced a small human boy from my body. he came quickly and not without provocation. the emergence of a child from the mother's body by way of the birth canal is simultaneously profound and unremarkable. it also really really really really really hurts a lot. it is also, like everything related to what women do with their bodies, very politically and emotionally loaded.

while i am proud of myself for having birthed without pain medication, i do not recommend it. i do not care how anyone else gives birth, because it is so specific, necessarily having to do with the mother and baby's health, the nature of the labor, the mother's relationship to her body, privacy, and pain (among other things), access to various resources, etc., etc. but here are some things i have to say about it, just in case you were wondering:

  • to reiterate: it really really really hurts. more than you think it will. more than you can express to anyone.
  • while the nature of the birth you want is important and relevant to many things, ultimately you have to parent for a much much longer time than you have to deliver the child. so, there are infinitely more factors involved in your relationship with the child than the few hours or days you spent bringing him into the world. which is to say in the scheme of things, measured by sheer hours logged, the kind of birth you have is a lot less important than a lot of other things.
  • while having as "natural" a childbirth as possible might confer some bragging rights, they are bragging rights along the lines of, say, climbing mount everest. which is to say, you might impress some people, but only a few people are really invested, and many people lead extremely fulfilling and achievement- and love-filled lives without having done it or even wanting to do it.
  • science has done some extremely awesome things regarding health and pain.
  • you have to really focus on what you want and really not care what other people think.* well-intentioned people say things that can hurt your feelings if, say, you had a c-section (even if everyone would have died without one). it's hard to drown out the cultural pressure.
  • however, even worse is your own terrible self who internalizes all that pressure. the women who feel bad about themselves for having an epidural after 48 hours of hard labor with no sleep or eating break my heart when i hear they are still beating themselves up about alleviating their pain and giving themselves a break. no matter what kind of birth you want or how invested you are in it, you are your own worst enemy in the pressure department. and you best start loving and forgiving that enemy, like they say you are supposed to.
  • if you give birth vaginally, you will poop in the process.** like, for sure. and also for sure, you will not care. dear reader, i can't guarantee much to you. but i can guarantee these two things.
  • if anyone thinks evolution strives toward improvement of a species, i would invite them to witness a birth. there's nothing perfected about the process. it is inefficient and devastating. it's barely good enough to get that one little baby out, and that's apparently all it has to be for this here species to slog on. so get off your high horse about humans being so awesome.

*like many (over?)educated middle class white women with a modicum of ability for self-reflection and a shred of a sense of humor, i identify strongly with tina fey. i am less funny and smart and do not have as strong of a work ethic. i might have her beat in the self-deprecation department, though. anyway, in bossypants she writes about how culturally loaded the issue of day care & nannies are, and also about Teat Nazis (cultural pressure around breastfeeding). it's the same deal with childbirth (see earlier point about how everything relating to women's bodies is loaded).

**tina fey claims not to have pooped. so maybe i also have her beat in the honesty or speaking-truth-to-abjection department.

Tuesday, August 09, 2011

civics lesson

if minor stresses induce labor, surely attendance at another government meeting where there are presenters from the Tea Party will bring this baby out.

i disagree on all manner of political matters with national figures, local commenters, friends, family, my spouse. that's just what happens. usually i recognize that those disagreements arise because we have different interests, or values, or perspectives, or experience, or something. even with many of those issues that i would really go to the mat for, i understand that people disagree from some reasonable reason. and of course, the whole point of sociable living and democracy and making knowledge and getting somewhere is disagreement. lest it be surmised that i envision some toga-and-marble-steps utopia, i should also add i get incredibly impatient when i perceive that the source of disagreement is the other person's fear, racism, general parsimony toward humanity, lack of curiosity, protectiveness of their own privileged status, or inability to imagine that there are other interests in the world besides their own.

i have, however, also experienced disagreement with people whose ability to simply name what happened or is happening (i.e., their relationship to facts) is compromised. i was reminded of my conversations with such people last night when i attended a local government meeting that featured presentations by tea partiers. i mean, i knew i didn't share values with their ilk.* what i didn't know was how throroughly their position is situated over a vast pool of quicksand comprised primarily of fear and paranoia and a repetition of "facts" that they generate and circulate among themselves and so which apparently become true in the repetition.

so, sure they're racist and reactionary and think property is the most important thing of all, ever, and they sneer at phrases like "ending poverty" and "environmental protection." fine. so, they're not nice people. but they also are delusional, and have worked each other up into a froth about the coming one-world government and how it's going to force people to move into, like, tenements together, and force rural communities to build subways or trolleys. even though none of them have suffered any loss of life, liberty or property, they all see such losses as an imminent threat, so that personal anecdotes fizzle out b/c nothing bad has happened to any of them, but what led up to nothing happening is evidence that SOMETHING IS HAPPENING. they occupy the bizarre and powerful epistemic position of a prophet of disaster, but it doesn't matter that the disaster never happens, because it always could.

these people, who are paranoid first and ask questions later, and then when they don't like the answers to those questions make up their own answers and then wrap it all up as a conspiracy against them that no one can prove doesn't exist, have gained and are gaining power. i knew i disagreed with them but i didn't know they lived in an alternate universe.

also, to file under "seemingly unrelated, but fair enough": luckily for us, during the main presentation, we noticed that the presenter had tucked his shirt into his underwear. nice!!



*though i thought maybe we could get together on the issue of american indian land rights? i mean, they're totally into property and against eminent domain, so surely that translates into objecting to the entire way this nation was founded? right?